Western vaccine policy boosted by Seneca College court decision: Lawyer
An Ontario Superior Court of Justice has sided with Seneca College in a non-binding, preliminary procedure over the school’s COVID-19 vaccination policy.
Seneca’s mandate — and the students’ challenge — bear similarities to a lawsuit brought by five Western students, claiming the university does not have the authority to implement its vaccine rules.
Among several points laid out in court filings acquired by CTV News London, the Western complaint seeks to apply a permanent injunction preventing the school from collecting students’ vaccination information, and order Western get rid of all records already gathered.
“The question put to Western is not whether it’s the right thing to do,” says local defense lawyer Gord Cudmore, who is not involved in the case. “The question is: do they have a legal right to do it?”
Based on the Seneca decision, Western appears to have the edge, says Cudmore.
“The students have every right to bring the challenge and argue it. It’s not frivolous,” says Cudmore. “But I don’t think it will win the day.”
One of the lawyers representing the Western students says their lawsuit will go ahead, despite the Seneca decision.
“The two cases are completely different,” says Lisa Bildy, an attorney with Libertas Law in London, Ont. “Seneca’s was a motion for a temporary injunction based on the Charter of Rights and Freedoms…Our lawsuit is based entirely on Western’s violation of privacy legislation.”
The notice of application viewed by CTV News London does not reference the Charter of Rights and Freedoms in it, instead focusing primarily on legislation laid out in the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act.
In addition, the claim cites Section 38(2) of the act, which states “no person shall collect person information on behalf of an institution unless the collection is…necessary to the proper administration of a lawfully authorized activity.”
The claim also states that because no other Ontario university requires vaccination, it is not necessary for providing post-secondary programming.
The case is scheduled for a hearing to weigh its merits on Sept. 19.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.7006831.1724127264!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
'America, I love you': Biden caps off night one of Democratic National Convention
U.S. President Joe Biden delivered his valedictory address to the Democratic National Convention on Monday night, as his decision to end his re-election bid released newfound energy within his party with Vice-President Kamala Harris′ elevation to the top of the ticket.
Protesters break through police fence near site of Democratic National Convention
Protesters broke through a fence set up by police near the site of the Democratic National Convention on its opening day Monday as thousands took to the streets to voice their opposition to the war in Gaza.
Donald Trump posts image of fake Taylor Swift endorsement
Former U.S. president Donald Trump has posted a fake social media image of pop superstar Taylor Swift asking people to vote for him in the November election.
Statistics Canada says median family after-tax income in 2022 down after inflation
Statistics Canada says the median family after-tax income in 2022 fell compared with 2021, after adjustment for inflation, with young people being the hardest hit.
Conservatives under fire after pulling 'Canadian Dream' video that may have shown Russian jets
The Conservative Party of Canada has deleted a video that promoted Canadian values but featured what the Defence Minister's office says are Russian fighter jets.
'The lady's dog might have been dead': Cambridge bylaws in question following serious dog attack
A Cambridge woman is calling for action after her dog was attacked by two off-leash dogs late last month.
Former NFL player arrested after allegedly hitting, then urinating on passenger during flight
A former NFL player accused of drunkenly hitting one man and urinating on another during a flight from Boston to Dublin has been arrested and charged with disorderly conduct, the Massachusetts State Police said Monday.
Youth charged after shooting in rural Sask. leaves woman, 18, dead
Saskatchewan RCMP say a male youth from Carry the Kettle Nakoda Nation is facing 10 charges, including manslaughter, after an 18-year-old woman was shot dead in Wolseley, Sask. early Sunday morning.
The man turning jet planes into cool houses
Over time, Jon Kotwicki says he and his team are 'creating, you know, kind of our own little airport amusement park' in Wasilla, Alaska.