Proposed by-law banning graphic anti-abortion flyers would likely face legal challenge
City council will soon consider two draft by-laws aimed at stopping the unsolicited distribution of graphic anti-abortion flyers in London, but the pro-life organization behind the campaign is already threatening a legal fight.
Flyers containing images of dead fetuses sparked outrage after they were dropped into many Londoners’ mailboxes in 2020.
“It’s very triggering for anyone picking up the mail that day,” explains Deanna Ronson with Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada. “A mom could have sent a child out to get it, or a woman who has recently experienced a miscarriage.”
In a new report, civic administration presents two draft by-laws for consideration.
The first would forbid delivery of any flyer or advertisement to residences that post ‘No Junk Mail’, ‘No Flyers’, or ‘No Unsolicited Mail’ on their mailbox.
Canada Post, newspapers, and election campaign literature would be exempt.
Violations result in a $75 fine, double for repeat offences.
The second draft by-law would forbid door to door distribution of any graphic images citywide.
Tickets would be $350 dollars, doubling for repeat offenders.
Graphic images would be defined as “a detailed pictorial image or series of images, containing potentially sensitive content that may cause or trigger a negative reaction to the health and wellbeing of any person at any scale. An example of a graphic image may include, but is not limited to, a dismembered human beings or aborted fetuses.”
Ronson says the second draft by-law would offer a deterrent if directed at individuals delivering flyers and organizations acting as distributors.
“I think that it addresses the specific issue and that it has a substantial penalty,” she says.
City council will have the option to approve one, both, or neither of the proposed by-laws.
Councillor Shawn Lewis and three colleagues originally asked staff to present council with options back in 2020.
“We do have the authority to enact by-laws that protect people from harm, so I think this is a really good option for us,” Lewis tells CTV News.
However, the organization behind the graphic anti-abortion flyers, the Canadian Centre for Bio-Ethical Reform (CCBR) warns it would launch a legal challenge if the by-law is enacted.
“The Supreme Court has said that content-based discrimination is unconstitutional. The proposed by-law would attempt to regulate and prohibit specific messages, exactly what no government has the legal authority to do,” writes Blaise Alleyne in an email to CTV News.
“CCBR would explore all legal options to respond to unconstitutional restrictions on our Charter right to freedom of expression,” he adds.
But Councillor Lewis is undeterred.
“Other municipalities have enacted by-laws to varying degrees of what’s proposed in ours, and I do think we have the authority to enact this by-law, so I am confident going forward it would withstand a challenge,” he asserts.
Ronson adds, “The right to freedom of expression is limited when that freedom of expression causes harm to individuals.”
The Community and Protective Services Committee will receive the report, and confidential legal advice, at a meeting on March 1.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.6962950.1720891900!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.jpg)
'Surreal 24 hours': What A-list guests think of Indian billionaire's wedding
Anant Ambani, the youngest son of Asia's richest man, ties the knot this weekend with longtime girlfriend Radhika Merchant at a Mumbai wedding dubbed the ceremony of the year – but what was it like to be one of the guests?
A Black man got a job interview after he changed the name on his resume. Now, he's suing for discrimination
A Black man has filed an employment discrimination lawsuit against a hotel in Detroit, Mich., alleging the hotel only offered him a job interview after he changed the name on his resume, according to a copy of the lawsuit obtained by CNN.
Former B.C. Realtor has licence cancelled, $130K in penalties for role in mortgage fraud
The provincial regulator responsible for policing B.C.'s real estate industry has ordered a former Realtor to pay $130,000 and cancelled her licence after determining that she committed a variety of professional misconduct.
Ontario driver has licence suspended for 13-year-old traffic ticket
An Ontario driver was shocked to get a letter in the mail saying her licence had been suspended over a traffic ticket she received 13 years ago.
Should you wait to buy or sell your home?
The Bank of Canada is expected to announce its key interest rate decision in less than two weeks. Last month, the bank lowered its key interest rate to 4.7 per cent, marking its first rate cut since March 2020.
Dr. Ruth Westheimer, America’s pioneering sex therapist, dies at 96
Dr. Ruth Westheimer, the diminutive sex therapist who became a pop icon, media star and best-selling author through her frank talk about once-taboo bedroom topics, has died. She was 96.
Kate, Princess of Wales to make rare public appearance at Wimbledon Sunday
The Princess of Wales is set to attend the Wimbledon men's final on Sunday in a rare public appearance after her cancer diagnosis.
Calls to enforce leash bylaws in North Vancouver after dog mauled to death
Doreen Manuel was walking her two small Yorkshire terriers last month when a large off-leash dog suddenly lunged at them.
5 people escape hot, acidic pond after SUV drove into inactive geyser in Yellowstone
Five people were able to escape a hot, acidic pond in Yellowstone National Park after the sport utility vehicle they were riding in went off the road and into an inactive geyser, park officials said Friday.